13 of the Spookiest Gifts for Your 2023 Halloween Themed Gift Exchange
There are no rules around gift exchanges here, so why not plan a virtual spooky party this Halloween to get everyone together. We’ve rounded up the best gift ideas at a variety of price ranges. Only treats here, no tricks!
Note: prices and availability are as-of publish date and may change; we may earn commissions for purchases made through Amazon links in this post
#1. Glass Skull Cups
We can’t stop staring at these glasses and we’re not sure if that’s a good thing? Either way, these striking cups are sure to be a hot item at your gift exchange.
Glass Skull Mug
$14
#2. Bone Stacking Game
Halloween is all about fun and games and this skull and crossbones stacking game is right on theme.
Stack the Bones Game
$35
#3. Pumpkin Carving Set
Step aside, novices. This set of pumpkin carving tools is for the advanced carver and comes with 12 carving tools in their own carrying bag. We’re already impressed.
Pumpkin Carving Tool Set
$24
#4. Candy Crypt
No Halloween is complete without an abundance of candy. These spooky little candies come in a coffin-shaped box to keep everything very on theme.
See’s Candy
$16
#5. Bones Domino Set
We actually can’t say it better than the retailer themself this time: “This 28 piece dominoes set is sure to tickle your funny bone! Have a humerus time!”. We’ll just leave that there.
Bones Domino Set
$20
#6. Mini Ghost Candles
Okay, we’ll admit that these fall more on the cute side than the spooky side. But honestly, who can resist these little guys?
Set of 3 Mini Ghost Candles
$20
#7. Scary Bingo
Everyone loves this classic game. Now you can play with these creepy but also adorable Halloween themed cards.
Scary Bingo
$20
#8. Halloween Cookie Cutters
Perfect for the baker (established or wanna-be) in the gift exchange group. This set comes with 7 large cookie cutters in all of the spooky shapes for the season.
Halloween Cookie Cutter Set
$9
#9. Haunted Cookie Kit
While we’re on the theme of baking. This spooky kit comes with everything you need to make your own little haunted COOKIE graveyard. I don’t think we need to say anything else.
Halloween Graveyard Cookie Kit
$20
#10. Spooky Misfortune Cookies
Fun misfortunes await inside these dark little cookies.
Set of 13 Dark Humor Misfortune Cookies
$20
#11. Skull Coin Bank
Whether you’re trying to save up for that special something or you’ve got kids in your group you can’t deny that this is one sharp looking piggy bank.
Black Skull Coin Bank
$20
#12. Pick Your Poison Card Game
This would-you-rather style game is perfect for groups of all ages, perfect for family white elephant parties.
Pick Your Poison Card Game
$13
#13. Halloween Adult Coloring Book
Could there be anything more soothing and stress-relieving that coloring in these beautiful pages of halloween themed art?
GOREgeous Coloring Book
$12